Ever craved that perfect New York slice, the kind that makes you want to fold it in half, its thin crust just pliable enough to hold the weight of the perfectly melted cheese and tangy sauce? That craving for authentic New York pizza can hit hard, especially when you’re miles away from the bustling streets of the Big Apple. But fret not, Fairfax VA pizza lovers! The search for that iconic taste doesn’t require a cross-state road trip. This guide will uncover the best places in Fairfax VA to find New York-style pizza, comparing their offerings and helping you choose the perfect slice.
Defining New York Pizza: What Makes it Special?
Before we dive into the best pizza joints Fairfax has to offer, let’s clarify what exactly constitutes “New York pizza.” It’s more than just a pie; it’s an experience, a culinary tradition passed down through generations. The key lies in a few crucial elements:
The All-Important Crust
The foundation of any great New York pizza is undoubtedly the crust. It’s thin, crispy on the bottom, and slightly chewy. It should be foldable, allowing you to easily devour your slice while standing on a street corner (or sitting comfortably at your table). The secret lies in the high-gluten flour used, which provides the elasticity and structure needed for that perfect fold. Specific baking techniques, often involving hand-tossing and stretching, also contribute to the crust’s unique texture and flavor.
The Sauce: Simple Perfection
Forget overly complicated sauces loaded with herbs and spices. A true New York pizza sauce is simple, yet flavorful. It’s made from high-quality tomatoes, often San Marzano, with just a touch of seasoning to enhance the natural sweetness and acidity. Fresh ingredients are paramount; the taste should be vibrant and complement the cheese and toppings, not overpower them.
The Cheese: Mozzarella Magic
Mozzarella is the classic choice for New York pizza, and the quality matters immensely. It should be fresh, melty, and slightly browned in spots. The quantity is also crucial; enough to provide that satisfying cheese pull, but not so much that it weighs down the crust.
The Oven: High Heat Heaven
Many traditional New York pizzerias use deck ovens, which bake the pizza directly on a stone surface. These ovens reach incredibly high temperatures, allowing the pizza to cook quickly and evenly, resulting in a crispy crust and perfectly melted cheese.
Now, let’s dispel a common myth: water. While some swear that New York’s tap water is the secret ingredient to its pizza dough, the truth is more nuanced. It’s the skill and tradition, combined with quality ingredients and proper baking techniques, that truly make New York pizza what it is.
Where to Find Authentic New York Pizza in Fairfax VA
Alright, enough talk! Let’s get to the good stuff – the best places in Fairfax VA to satisfy your New York pizza cravings.
Benny Marzano’s
Located on Main Street, Benny Marzano’s brings a taste of New York’s giant slice culture to Fairfax. As part of a larger chain, they stick to the simple formula: massive pizzas, thin crust, and fresh ingredients.
The crust is surprisingly crispy for a pizza of this size, and the sauce has a bright, tangy flavor. The cheese is plentiful and evenly distributed. Ordering a whole pizza is impressive, but a slice is more manageable for most. They offer a limited menu of classic toppings, focusing on perfecting the basics. The price point is reasonable, especially considering the size of the slices. The ambiance is casual and bustling, perfect for a quick and satisfying meal. Benny Marzano’s is a great choice when you need to feed a crowd or just want a ridiculously large slice. Their classic cheese pizza is a must-try. They deserve a solid 4 out of 5 stars.
Pupatella Neapolitan Pizza
While technically Neapolitan, Pupatella offers a style that appeals to New York pizza lovers with its thin, chewy crust and fresh ingredients. Though not strictly a New York style, the emphasis on quality and simplicity resonates with those seeking an authentic experience.
Their wood-fired pizzas have a slightly charred crust, a characteristic of Neapolitan style, but it lends a delightful smoky flavor. The sauce is made from San Marzano tomatoes, resulting in a sweet and acidic flavor. The mozzarella is fresh and creamy, and the toppings are sourced locally whenever possible. Their Margherita pizza is a classic for a reason, showcasing the quality of their ingredients. Pupatella offers a more upscale dining experience compared to some other pizza joints, with a cozy atmosphere and friendly service. The price point is slightly higher, but the quality justifies the cost. Pupatella is a great option when you’re looking for a sophisticated pizza experience. I give them 4.5 out of 5 stars. You need to try the Margherita.
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza, while a chain, delivers a consistently delicious pie that many consider to be in the New York style realm. The key is their coal-fired oven, which imparts a unique smoky flavor and a crispy char to the crust.
The crust is thin and slightly charred, giving it a delightful texture and taste. The sauce is simple and flavorful, and the cheese is melted to perfection. They offer a wide variety of toppings, from classic pepperoni to more adventurous options like roasted peppers and caramelized onions. Their White Pizza, topped with ricotta cheese, garlic, and mozzarella, is a standout. The ambiance is lively and energetic, making it a great place for a casual meal with friends or family. The price point is moderate, making it accessible to a wide range of diners. Anthony’s is a reliable choice for a consistently good pizza experience. I give them 4 out of 5 stars. Their coal fired wings are not bad either.
Beyond the Slice: Other Important Factors
Choosing the perfect pizza place isn’t just about the taste; several other factors can influence your decision:
- **Delivery Options:** Do they deliver to your area? What are their delivery fees and estimated wait times?
- **Takeout Options:** Is it easy to order and pick up your pizza for a quick and convenient meal?
- **Dine-In Experience:** What’s the atmosphere like? Is it a casual spot or a more formal restaurant? Is there ample seating?
- **Dietary Restrictions:** Do they offer gluten-free crusts or vegetarian/vegan options?
- **Family-Friendly:** Is the restaurant suitable for children? Do they offer a kids’ menu?
- **Deals and Promotions:** Do they have any special deals or discounts that can help you save money?
Fairfax VA New York Pizza: Find Your Perfect Slice
Fairfax VA might not be New York City, but it offers a surprising number of delicious New York pizza options. From the massive slices at Benny Marzano’s to the wood-fired perfection at Pupatella and the coal-fired goodness at Anthony’s, there’s a slice out there to satisfy every craving. Remember, the “perfect” pizza is a matter of personal preference. So, get out there, try these recommended spots, and share your own experiences in the comments below!
Do you have any other favorite New York pizza places in Fairfax VA? Let us know in the comments!
